Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephanie Greene's avatar

Oh my friend, thank you for sharing this story about what happened to the Aleutian people. I hadn’t heard it before and it feels so important to hold with reverence and grief. I’m grateful you laid it here on this community table.

This was the first book I’ve read from Louise Erdrich so it warms me to know you’ve enjoyed her other work (I’m adding a few to my TBR pile now). I hope it helps to hear that she does eventually answer the question about a white couple raising a native child, but I didn’t include the reasoning here because of spoilers. I’d be interested to hear your thoughts after reading so I hope you’ll come back here when you do.

Expand full comment
Sodak's avatar

I am writing from Western South Dakota, not far from the Pine Ridge Reservation where I once taught. Thanks for your wonderful review. There are only a few Louise Erdrich novels that I haven’t read, including this one. She also contributed at least in some degree to “The Broken Chord” attributed to her then husband, Michael Dorris. I have purchased most of her books and I’ve saved a few to savor sometime in the future…sort of like the stash of Halloween candy I often kept through November as a child. I have realized (and have happily forgiven Ms. Erdrich) that many of her books have unexplainable (or just unexplained) parts and pieces, so it will be easy for me to accept not ever knowing why a native child was being raised by a non-native couple…. I find her tales so beautifully enchanting.

On another note, two summers ago I was preparing to teach in Southwestern Alaska. While learning about the people who have lived on the Aleutian Islands and Alaska Peninsula for thousands of years, sadly, I learned about their brutal decimation by Russian fur traders—before Seward’s Folly replaced these Russian exploiters with American ones. I don’t remember the exact horrific number… but 90% (including deaths from smallpox, etc.) is very believable. One of the most recent tragedies involved removing all the inhabitants from at least two villages, along the westernmost edge of the island chain, after the Japanese invaded the Aleutians. The displaced Native people were mostly housed in an old vacant cannery on the mainland, and many died thanks to the terrible conditions. Incidentally, the survivors were never returned to their ancestral villages when the war ended. I felt, and still do, such deep sadness when I learned all of this. I’ve spoken with a couple of people who currently live or recently lived there (I didn't end up going) and find the glimpse of the life they generously shared with me inspiring and hopeful despite the unimaginable tragedy.

Expand full comment

No posts